Authors:
Bhattacharya S. Cameron IM. Parkin DE. Abramovich DR. Mollison J. Pinion SB. Alexander DA. Grant A. Kitchener HC.
Institution:
Dr. S. Bhattacharya, Assisted Reproduction Unit, Aberdeen Maternity Hospital, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB9 2ZD; United Kingdom.
Title:
A pragmatic randomised comparison of transcervical resection of the endometrium with endometrial laser ablation for the treatment of menorrhagia (1997-1746).
Source:
British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. Vol 104(5) (pp01-607), 1997.
Abstract:
Objectives:
To compare endometrial laser ablation (ELA) with transcervical resection of the endometrium (TCRE) in the treatment of menorrhagia.
Design:
Randomised controlled trial.
Setting:
Gynaecology department of a large teaching hospital.
Participants:
Women with menorrhagia due to dysfunctional uterine bleeding (n = 372) were randomly allocated to ELA (n = 188) or TCRE (n = 184).
Settings, Design and Main Outcome Measures:
Operative complications, post-operative recovery, relief of menstrual and other symptoms, need for further surgical treatment, satisfaction with treatment after 6 and 12 months, and differential resource use.
Results:
TCRE was significantly quicker, with lower rates of fluid overload. Perioperative morbidity was low and similar in both groups. Outcome at 12 months was also similar: 72 women (45%) had either amenorrhoea or brown discharge in the ELA group compared with 71 (49%) in the TCRE group; 79 (49%) versus 68 (46%) had lighter periods. Thirty (16%) versus 36 (20%) had received further surgical treatment: 9 (5%) compared with 25 (14%) had had a hysterectomy, and 21 (11%) versus 11 (6%) had received repeat ablation. Anxiety and depression, dysmenorrhoea and pre-menstrual symptoms were improved by both procedures and bladder symptoms were affected by neither. At 12 months 148 (90%) women in the ELA group and 140 (91%) women in the TCRE group were satisfied with their treatment. The estimated additional cost of ELA was (L) 145 per procedure.
Conclusions:
At one year there was no clear difference in clinical outcome between ELA and TCRE. Both procedures were associated with low morbidity. ELA was the more costly procedure. Despite the need for further surgery for about one in six women, satisfaction rates were high following both ELA and TCRE.
Please click on the required question.
- 1 Are heavy periods a common problem?
- 2 What is in my menstrual flow?
- 3 What range of menstrual cycle length is considered to be normal?
- 4 How can menstrual blood loss be measured?
- 5 How can I tell if my periods are abnormally heavy?
- 6 What could be the cause of my very heavy menstrual periods?
- 7 I have been sterilised. Could this be the cause of my heavy periods?
- 8 Should I have tests to find the reason for my heavy periods?
- 9 How will my heavy period problems be investigated?
- 10 What is meant by anaemia due to heavy periods?
- 11 What is intermenstrual bleeding?
- 12 What is a hysteroscopy and D and C?
- 13 What is cervical cautery?
- 14 What happens after the D and C?
- 15 What treatments are available for my heavy periods?
- 16 What are the medical treatments available for heavy periods?
- 17 How do the various medical treatments for heavy periods work?
- 18 What would be reasonable initial treatment for a teenager or young woman with heavy periods?
- 19 What is a hysterectomy?
- 20 What are the indications for hysterectomy?
- 21 What are the risks (complications) of hysterectomy?
- 22 What is vault granulation?
- 23 What are the different types of hysterectomy?
- 24 Is it essential to remove the neck of the womb at hysterectomy?
- 25 Should my ovaries be removed or conserved during hysterectomy?
- 26 How long will I be in hospital when I have my hysterectomy?
- 27 I have had a hysterectomy. Do I still need to have smear tests?
- 28 What are the other surgical alternatives to hysterectomy?
- 29 How do endometrial ablation and hysterectomy compare?
- 30 Are there any psychological effects following hysterectomy?
- 31 How do we decide the best treatment for my period problems?
- 32 Could I have some recommended hysterectomy support groups?
- 33 Are there any support groups?
- Intermenstrual Bleeding - Bleeding between periods.
Thank you for choosing to visit us.
This is the personal website of David A Viniker MD FRCOG, Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist at Whipps Cross University Hospital, London - Specialist Interests - Reproductive Medicine including Infertility, PCOS, PMS, Menopause and HRT.
I do hope that you find the answers to your women's health questions in the patient information and medical advice provided.
