Authors:
Sculpher MJ. Bryan S. Dwyer N. Hutton J. Stirrat GM.
Institution:
Health Economics Research Group, Brunel University,Uxbridge, Middlesex UB8 3PH; United Kingdom.
Title:
An economic evaluation of transcervical endometrial resection versus abdominal hysterectomy for the treatment of menorrhagia (1993-923).
Source:
British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. Vol 100(3) (pp44-252), 1993.
Abstract:
Objectives:
To evaluate the relative health service cost of endometrial resection versus abdominal hysterectomy for the treatment of menorrhagia and the value women attach to their health state before and after surgery.
Design:
A prospective economic evaluation running alongside a randomised controlled trial.
Setting:
The gynaecology department of a teaching hospital. Subjects 200 women requiring surgical treatment of menorrhagia between January 1990 and May 1991; after withdrawals, 97 women underwent hysterectomy and 99 underwent endometrial resection.
Settings, Design and Main Outcome Measures:
The total health service cost of managing women in the two arms of the trial until 4 months after their operation. The change in women's valuation of their health state a fortnight after and a minimum of 4 months after surgery relative to that 1 month prior to their operation.
Results:
Total health service costs are significantly higher amongst abdominal hysterectomy patients (mean #1059.73) than amongst endometrial resection patients with a mean difference of #499.68 (95% CI #432-#567). This significant difference exists under alternative assumptions about the difference in lengths of stay in hospital between the two treatment groups and the hotel cost per in-patient day. On a scale of 0 to 100, relative to a month before surgery, there is a statistically significant difference in favour of endometrial resection between the two groups in the increase in value women attach to their health state at a fortnight after surgery (mean difference 11.2; 95% CI 0.6-21.7), but not at a minimum of 4 months after surgery (mean difference 7; 95% CI - 17.4 to 3.4).
Conclusions:
On the basis of health service resource cost up to 4 months after surgery, endometrial resection has a cost advantage over abdominal hysterectomy. However, given the fact that a subgroup of women requires retreatment due to resection failure and that this study considers a relatively short period of follow up, the long term costs and benefits of endometrial resection need to be evaluated before widespread diffusion is justified.
Please click on the required question.
- 1 Are heavy periods a common problem?
- 2 What is in my menstrual flow?
- 3 What range of menstrual cycle length is considered to be normal?
- 4 How can menstrual blood loss be measured?
- 5 How can I tell if my periods are abnormally heavy?
- 6 What could be the cause of my very heavy menstrual periods?
- 7 I have been sterilised. Could this be the cause of my heavy periods?
- 8 Should I have tests to find the reason for my heavy periods?
- 9 How will my heavy period problems be investigated?
- 10 What is meant by anaemia due to heavy periods?
- 11 What is intermenstrual bleeding?
- 12 What is a hysteroscopy and D and C?
- 13 What is cervical cautery?
- 14 What happens after the D and C?
- 15 What treatments are available for my heavy periods?
- 16 What are the medical treatments available for heavy periods?
- 17 How do the various medical treatments for heavy periods work?
- 18 What would be reasonable initial treatment for a teenager or young woman with heavy periods?
- 19 What is a hysterectomy?
- 20 What are the indications for hysterectomy?
- 21 What are the risks (complications) of hysterectomy?
- 22 What is vault granulation?
- 23 What are the different types of hysterectomy?
- 24 Is it essential to remove the neck of the womb at hysterectomy?
- 25 Should my ovaries be removed or conserved during hysterectomy?
- 26 How long will I be in hospital when I have my hysterectomy?
- 27 I have had a hysterectomy. Do I still need to have smear tests?
- 28 What are the other surgical alternatives to hysterectomy?
- 29 How do endometrial ablation and hysterectomy compare?
- 30 Are there any psychological effects following hysterectomy?
- 31 How do we decide the best treatment for my period problems?
- 32 Could I have some recommended hysterectomy support groups?
- 33 Are there any support groups?
- Intermenstrual Bleeding - Bleeding between periods.
Thank you for choosing to visit us.
This is the personal website of David A Viniker MD FRCOG, Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist at Whipps Cross University Hospital, London - Specialist Interests - Reproductive Medicine including Infertility, PCOS, PMS, Menopause and HRT.
I do hope that you find the answers to your women's health questions in the patient information and medical advice provided.
